The Role of Visceral Hypersensitivity in Irritable Bowel Syndrome: Pharmacological Targets and Novel Treatments
1Pharmaceutical Sciences Research Center, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran
2Medical Biology Research Center, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran
3Faculty of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
4Endocrinology and Metabolism Research Center, Endocrinology and Metabolism Clinical Sciences Institute, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
5Department of Traditional Pharmacy, School of Traditional Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
*Correspondence: Mohammad Abdollahi and Roja Rahimi are equally responsible for this study. Mohammad Abdollahi, PharmD, PhD, Faculty of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; Endocrinology and Metabolism Research Center, Endocrinology and Metabolism Clinical Sciences Institute, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran 1417614411, Iran, Tel: +98-2166959104, Fax: +98-2166959104, E-mail: mohammad.abdollahi@utoronto.ca. Roja Rahimi, PharmD, PhD, Department of Traditional Pharmacy, School of Traditional Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran 1417653761, Iran, Tel: +98-2166412653, Fax: +98-2166412653, E-mail: rojarahimi@gmail.comAbstract
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is the most common disorder referred to gastroenterologists and is characterized by altered bowel habits, abdominal pain, and bloating. Visceral hypersensitivity (VH) is a multifactorial process that may occur within the peripheral or central nervous systems and plays a principal role in the etiology of IBS symptoms. The pharmacological studies on selective drugs based on targeting specific ligands can provide novel therapies for modulation of persistent visceral hyperalgesia. The current paper reviews the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying therapeutic targeting for providing future drugs to protect or treat visceroperception and pain sensitization in IBS patients. There are a wide range of mediators and receptors participating in visceral pain perception amongst which substances targeting afferent receptors are attractive sources of novel drugs. Novel therapeutic targets for the management of VH include compounds which alter gut-brain pathways and local neuroimmune pathways. Molecular mediators and receptors participating in pain perception and visceroperception include histamine-1 receptors, serotonin (5-hydrodytryptamine) receptors, transient receptor potential vanilloid type I, tachykinins ligands, opioid receptors, voltage-gated channels, tyrosine receptor kinase receptors, protease-activated receptors, adrenergic system ligands, cannabinoid receptors, sex hormones, and glutamate receptors which are discussed in the current review. Moreover, several plant-derived natural compounds with potential to alleviate VH in IBS have been highlighted. VH has an important role in the pathology and severity of complications in IBS. Therefore, managing VH can remarkably modulate the symptoms of IBS. More preclinical and clinical investigations are needed to provide efficacious and targeted medicines for the management of VH.
Introduction
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is the most common disorder referred to gastroenterologists, which is commonly characterized by altered bowel habit, abdominal pains, bloating, and is associated with psychological disorders.1–4 It is a common gut disorder with a prevalence of 9–23%5 which varies amongst different geographical regions and countries, with a higher prevalence in Western Europe and North America compared with other parts of the world which could be explained by a relationship between western lifestyle and gut health.6,7 Abdominal pain is a prevalent disorder within a healthy population; however, severe and recurrent pain sensation is observed frequently in IBS patients. Such painful sensation released from the gut is considered as the main cause of medical consultation in patients with IBS.1,2,8,9 While IBS is not amongst the life-threatening diseases, the intense impact of IBS on various aspects of the patient’s life leads to drawing greater global attention to this disease.1,2,10 The economic burden of IBS complications which include direct costs (diagnostic practices, consultations, and treatments) and also indirect costs (low work productivity and enhanced work absenteeism) are appraised to be between €700–1600 per patient in each year within Europe. Thus, the economic burden which has been reported to IBS managing indicates an impressive social expenditure.1,11
Several underlying mechanisms could be discussed in the pathophysiology of IBS as a multifactorial disease. Inflammatory reactions, history of childhood infections,12 hypersensitivity and alteration in visceral perception,13,14 gastrointestinal dysmotility, changes in gut microflora, emotional and psychological triggers, increase in intestinal permeability and food intolerance as well as genetic variations in bile acid secretion are amongst suggested reasons for IBS development.15,16
Conventional Treatment of Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Due to the wide range of IBS clinical manifestations, several treatment strategies are used to control the disease symptoms.17,18 Classic pharmacotherapy of IBS includes management of diarrhea/ constipation, abdominal pain, and bloating. In diarrhea-predominant IBS (IBS-D), antidiarrheal agents like loperamide are used to control the symptoms; though, recent studies are considering other types of drugs like mesalazine in the management of diarrhea.19 On the other hand, constipation could be controlled with polyethylene glycol and lactulose as well as bulking agents (Psyllium and bran), milk of magnesia and stimulant laxatives (senna and bisacodyl).20 Other agents include anticholinergics and antispasmodics for abdominal pain and carminatives for flatulence.21 In addition, new drug categories are being investigated for IBS management, which, at least in part, focus on the psychological aspects of the disease pathophysiology. Several antidepressants, including imipramine, clomipramine and nortriptyline from tricyclic antidepressants as well as citalopram and fluoxetine from selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors were tested in human subjects to control IBS symptoms; nevertheless, more clinical evidences are needed to confirm the effects of antidepressants.22,23
Visceral Hypersensitivity
Functions of visceral organs, such as gastrointestinal distensions and contractions, in non-pathological conditions has normally no pain. Altered sensation in response to physiological stimuli is defined as visceral hypersensitivity (VH). Pressure or volume augmentations applied to the bowel induced mechanical stimuli. In clinical manifestation, VH is defined as an enhanced perception of mechanical triggers applied to the bowel which seems as pain and discomfort.24,25 VH is a disorder of biopsychosocial diseases as in functional dyspepsia or IBS. Two major components of VH are allodynia and hyperalgesia. Hyperalgesia is defined as an intensified pain sensation in response to stimuli which usually provoke pain, whereas allodynia refers to the elevated nociceptive sensation in response to normal stimuli. Previous studies exhibited that VH is generated from disturbance in the peripheral sensory pathway and/or central nervous system (CNS). In fact, VH is known as decreased thresholds of stimuli perception generated from the gastrointestinal tract.24–26 Epidemiological surveys have demonstrated different estimation of prevalence of VH in patients with IBS which varied from 33% to 90%.27–29 VH generally occurs in IBS-D patients, who have increased intestinal permeability.13,30 Clinical studies demonstrated that the severity of IBS complications in patients with hypersensitivity IBS is dramatically higher than other IBS patients. Although primary investigations have restricted the occurrence of VH to the rectum and sigmoid colon, numerous studies reported that decreased thresholds of nociceptive sensation were observed within other parts of the gut including the small bowel, stomach, as well as the esophagus, indicating the spread of VH within all over the gut.26,28,31,32
Pathophysiology and Etiology of Visceral Hypersensitivity
For the first time in 1973, it was observed that pain responses to rectal balloon distensions in patients with IBS are remarkably higher than healthy subjects. Afterwards, a large body of clinical studies has reported that pain perception as well as discomfort in response to rectal distension are intensified in IBS patients, which indicates the contribution of VH in IBS symptoms.26,33,34 The exact pathogenesis of the VH and association of altered visceroperception in clinical symptoms of IBS has not been unveiled; though, recent pathophysiological investigations have recognized a wide range of features which result in gastrointestinal dysmotility and visceral sensitivity via initiating complex cascades. In fact, VH condition is a multifactorial process that may occur both within the peripheral nervous system and at the level of CNS function. Several factors, including microbial infections, intestinal microbiota, psychological factors, inflammation and immunological factors, brain-gut communication, diet, as well as genes, are involved in the manifestation of gastrointestinal symptoms of IBS particularly VH.33,35–37 Given the fact that IBS can be induced via an acute episode of infective gastroenteritis indicates the significant role of peripheral factors involving pain perception in IBS.35,36 Likewise, it is suggested that psychosocial factors possess a pivotal role in bowel motility and visceral sensation. Patients with IBS showed a higher incidence of depression (20–30%) or anxiety (15–45%) in comparison to healthy individuals. It has been confirmed that these factors are involved in the severity of IBS symptoms and visceral pain via affecting brain-gut interaction, central pain perception, and intestinal motor function.38 In addition, intestinal permeability is among the key factors associated with the severity of IBS complications and visceral sensitization.33
Disturbance in the immune system of the gastrointestinal tract, neural pathways, gut endocrine characteristics as well as microbiological condition of the gut alters nociceptive transmission from the periphery to the brain via sensory nerve signaling in large subsets of subjects with IBS.39 Commensal intestinal bacteria as well as gut pathogens can obviously alter visceral nociception mediated by regulating visceral afferents directly or through a disturbing gut barrier function and intestinal immune system.40,41 Accumulating evidence suggests that disturbance in the enteric neuroendocrine system is an important contributor in altered intestinal perception.42
Clinical investigations have reported that microRNA expression increases in the colonic tissue of IBS patients. It has been found that these microRNAs can promote epigenetic and genetic events through modulating intestinal pathways, such as 5-HT signaling which result in intestinal permeability and somatic hypersensitivity in IBS patients.43 Intestinal tissue inflammation possesses the potential to alter gut wall function, increasing the release of inflammatory mediators which lead to stimulation of sensory afferent nerve endings within the gastrointestinal tract. Inflammation is able to cause post-inflammatory hyperalgesia and is among the principal local factors involved in VH occurring in patients with IBS.44 Distal peripheral afferents including mucosal afferents, serosal and mesenteric afferents, as well as muscular afferents have a principal role in gut-brain axis communication. It has been confirmed that one of the main mechanisms involved in the pathophysiology of VH in IBS symptoms is sensitization of the distal peripheral afferents. In response to a transient inflammation, amongst distal peripheral afferents, the mesenteric and serosal afferents within the splanchnic pathway regulate prolonged visceral sensitization. Likewise, these afferents also possess chemosensitivity to a wide range of agents such as ATP and bradykinin, which result in induction of post-inflammatory VH. Besides, mechanically insensitive afferents within the colorectal pelvic and lumbar splanchnic pathways possess the potential to acquire mechanosensitivity causing neural activation in pathological inflammatory conditions.45
Pharmacological Aspects of Visceral Hypersensitivity and Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Novel therapeutic agents for the management of VH include compounds which alter gut-brain pathways and local neuroimmune pathways. Since gastrointestinal hyperalgesia is commonly associated with muscular spasms, molecules attenuating contractions of gut smooth muscles can improve VH. In addition, therapeutic agents which are able to suppress neural activation and signaling from the gastrointestinal tract to the CNS possess a principal role in controlling VH. Below are the main molecular targets corresponding with improving VH in IBS.4,39
Immunological and Inflammatory Pathways
Several inflammatory mediators, including neuropeptides, cytokines, and prostanoids have a pivotal role in the peripheral sensitization of mucosal neuronal afferents and VH. It has been reported that elevated amount of mast cells is associated with visceral hyperalgesia. Clinical trials on IBS patients revealed that the amount of activated mast cells within the proximity of bowel enteric nerves is associated with the incidence and severity of enhanced vis-ceroperception.46–48 Animal models of post-infectious gut dysfunction exhibited that inflammatory pathways obviously affect sensory motor performance. Clinical evaluation showed that gastrointestinal levels of prostaglandin E2 as well as immune cells, including CD25+ T cells were elevated in the intestinal mucosa of patients with IBS. Likewise, mRNA expression of the pro-inflammatory mediator, IL-1β, has been reported in patients with post-infectious IBS. It has been suggested that the pro-inflammatory cytokines affect the performance of enteric nerves as well as sensory innervations with the motivation of irregular secretomotor responses within the gastrointestinal tract, causing altered pain threshold and visceral sensory perception which resulted in the generation of gut pain and discomfort.46–48 Human studies demonstrated that 5-aminosalicylic acid, an anti-inflammatory drug in the gut, significantly alleviates pain perception mediated by reducing intestinal immune cells.19,49,50
Toll-like receptors (TLRs) have a crucial role in encoding specific receptors involved in abnormal visceral perception. Within the pathogenesis of post-infectious IBS, TLRs, particularly TLR9, modulate host immune reactions to enteric bacteria and encode defense proteins in the epithelial barrier. Moreover, TLRs is involved in the motivation of neuroimmune responses which is activated by psychological stress in patients with VH.51,52 Intravenous, intracerebroventricular, and also the intraprefrontal cortex administration of TAK-242, which is a specific antagonist of TLR4, remarkably suppressed VH induced by chronic stress.53
Histamine-1 Receptor
According to clinical investigations, histamine-1 receptors are significantly elevated in intestinal and colonic mucosa of IBS patients in comparison to healthy subjects. Mucosal release of histamine and tryptase, mediators of mast cell is considered as one the contributors in the activation of visceral nociceptive sensory pathways.54–56 It is assumed that antagonists of histamine-1 receptors, which are biologically restricted to peripheral organs, have the ability to manage hypersensitivity and motility. An animal study on altered visceral perception revealed that second generation antagonists of histamine-1 receptors, including ebastine and fexofenadine can remarkably alleviate stress associated VH.54 Ketotifen, which is an antagonist of histamine-1 receptor and a mast cell stabilizer, can significantly reverse hyperalgesia and relieve discomfort and abdominal pain, as well as clinical digestive symptoms in IBS patients with VH.56
Serotonin
Serotonin (5-hydrodytryptamine; 5-HT) is an important neurotransmitter and paracrine signaling substance which mediates mutual communication between the brain and the gut. In the human body, this molecule is mainly (90–95%) produced by the enterochromaffin cells of the intestinal mucosa as well as by subgroups of enteric neurons. 5-HT is the responsible agent for bloating, nausea, vomiting, and chemotherapy associated pain.57,58 A large body of evidence confirmed that mucosal stimulation causes 5-HT release, which results in induction of the peristaltic reflex. Targeting 5-HT receptors as well as 5-HT uptake mechanisms possess a key role in the production of effective treatment in VH associated disorders.58,59 A clinical study of patients with IBS suffering from VH exhibited that alosetron, a 5-HT3 receptor antagonist, can significantly improve gastrointestinal symptoms, including higher volume thresholds and reducing colonic compliance.60 Subsequent to aversive rectal exciting, alosetron obviously reduces the emotional motor system of brain activity leading to modulation of the gut sensitivity.61 In addition, tegaserod which is a partial agonist of 5-HT4 receptor significantly reduced sensitivity to rectal distension and improved visceral sensation in both patients and healthy subjects.62–64
The 5-HT7 receptor which participates in nociceptor activation and its chemical antagonists have a strong rationale for drug development to manage functional gut disorders, particularly visceral sensitivity. 5-HT7 receptors are expressed in afferent nociceptors terminating in the superficial layers of the spinal cord. Inhibiting 5-HT7 receptors causes the elevation of pressure threshold which results in blockage of stimulating intestinal peristalsis and reduction of bowel compliance. Nevertheless, our knowledge about this 5-HT subgroup is restricted and the perfect mechanism of this receptor in brain-gut axis must be found.57,65
Transient Receptor Potential Vanilloid Type I
Transient receptor potential vanilloid type I (TRPV1) is a significant contributor in colorectal mechanosensation as well as inflammation-induced pain. TRPV1 is a member of the family of TRP receptors expressed within the nervous system of the brain, especially on small-to-medium sized neurons, and there is a strong motivation on TRPV1 for drug discovery in relation to VH.66,67
In response to intestinal inflammatory conditions, locally produced nerve growth factor (NGF) modulates the expression of TRPV1 and enhances the sensitivity of the receptor. In fact, NGF-mediated p38 kinase pathway is involved in enhancing the expression of TRPV1 which is mediated by the inflammatory cytokines, PGs and bradykinin. Activation of TRPV1 is related to protein kinase C as well as cAMP-dependent protein kinase which cause phosphorylation of the receptor, resulting in facilitation of colorectal afferent neuron sensitization. In contrast, protein phosphatases mediate dephosphorylation of TRPV1 leading to its desensitization. Experimental studies have showed that TRPV1 is activated by capsaicin and its analogues, as well as other substances like resinif-eratoxin. Clinical investigations revealed that the levels of TRPV-1 are elevated in patients with rectal hypersensitivity and that there is a significant association between the enhancement of TRPV-1 and sensory response to rectal distension.68,69 Likewise, TRPV1 has a principal role in the induction and maintenance of persistent colonic sensitivity, which is induced by neonatal colon irritation in rats. There is considerable interest in targeting TRPV1 receptors and neuronal growth factors in order to discover novel therapies for alleviating visceral pain. Intraperitoneal injection of TRPV1 antagonists significantly reduced sensitivity of the colon to balloon distention in adult rats compared with control animals.70 SB366791, a TRPV1 antagonist, noticeably inhibited CCL2- induced thermal hyperalgesia mediated by suppressing nociceptive signaling and synaptic transmission.71 TRPV1 antagonists like capsazepine modulate inflammatory associated visceral pain and disease severity in dextran sodium sulfate-induced IBD.67,72
Tachykinins
Tachykinins are specific peptides including neurokinin (NK) A and B, and also substance P which are expressed within the small diameter sensory fibers of the gut. These peptides affect NK1, NK2, as well as NK3 receptors, which are expressed within the CNS as well as the autonomic nervous system. Current experimental studies have demonstrated the significant role of NK receptors in VH. It has been reported that NK receptors as well as substance P affect sensory neurons and are involved in nociceptive sensation. In vivo studies showed that SR-140333 and MEN-10930, 2 selective antagonists of NK1 receptors, possess significant alleviating effects on inflammatory associated hyperalgesia.73–75 Different animal studies have confirmed that nepadutant and saredutant, 2 NK2 antagonists, can significantly modulate the colorectal hypersensitivity to distension. Talnetant, SB-223412, and SR-142801 are amongst the selective antagonists of NK3 receptors. Peripheral administration of SR-142801 suppresses inflammatory associated VH.74–77
Opioid Receptors
Opioid receptors, including δ, μ, and κ receptors are expressed within submucosal and myenteric plexus of the gut, and also visceral nociceptive sensory pathways. A large body of investigations reported that opioid receptors play an important role in modulating gut secretion and motility, as well as colorectal perception. Experimental studies exhibited that fedotozine and asimadoline are among agonists of κ-opioid receptors which can significantly reduce pain sensation.78,79 In a clinical trial on patients with IBS, fedotozine significantly decreased volume or pressure stimuli perception. Likewise, in another clinical study, asimadoline alleviated functional dyspepsia symptoms, particularly hyperalgesia.79,80 It has been found that activation of μ-opioid receptors by exogenous opioids can reduce bowel transition. Eluxadoline, a μ-opioid receptor agonist and δ-opioid receptor antagonist, showed a significant elevation in pain threshold in IBS-D patients.80,81
Tyrosine Receptor Kinase Receptors
Tyrosine receptor kinase (Trk) receptors, a group of tyrosine kinases, possess modulatory activity on synaptic plasticity as well as adjustment of neuronal transmission strength within the nervous system. It has been found that the level of the Trk high affinity receptor (TrkA) expressing fibers is significantly elevated in patients with rectal hypersensitivity and fecal urgency. It has been recognized that amongst Trk receptors (A, B, and C), TrkA is mainly expressed in nociceptive sensory neurons. Neurotrophins, particularly NGF, are amongst the main molecules that act on Trk receptors and TrkA possess the highest affinity to this substance.82,83 k252A, a TrkA antagonist, significantly attenuated VH to colorectal distension induced by chronic stress-induced in mice.84 Visceral inflammation stimulates TrkB which is commonly expressed in visceral afferents through brain-derived neurotrophic factors and results in regulating painful sensation. Preclinical examinations confirmed that systemic NGF induces hyperalgesia mediated by activation of peripheral terminals in nociceptive neurons.82,83,85
Voltage-gated Channels
Voltage-gated channels are stimulated by tissue-damaging motivations, which cause alterations in pain thresholds mediated by increase in sensitivity of peripheral neurons. Voltage-gated potassium channels have a principal role in regulating neuronal activation; thus, peripheral hypersensitivity can be obviously modulated via blocking potassium currents. The 2 major types of voltage-gated potassium channels are the sustained delayed rectifier current and the transient A-type current.86,87 The increased level of potassium can lead to depolarization of the cell membrane in smooth muscles, which is associated with the entry of extracellular calcium ions as well as stimulation of bowel contractions. It has been suggested that ryanodine and inositol triphosphate receptors are involved in depolarization-induced calcium currents in muscle cells.87
In electrically motivated cells, voltage-gated calcium channels provide the main current of Ca2+ from extracellular tissue to the cytosol. Voltage-gated calcium channels consist of pore forming α1 subunits as well as different smaller subunits such as β, γ, α2, and δ. Marger et al88 reported that elevation of the current density in the T type calcium channel (a subfamily of voltage-gated calcium channels) within colonic nociceptors can exacerbate VH. Calcium channel antagonists, mibefradil, ethosuximide, and NP078585 can remarkably inhibit butyrate-induced VH in rats.
Voltage-gated sodium channels produce the rising phase of the action potential mediated by enhancing sodium ion permeability in the neuronal cell membrane. They can also reduce the activation threshold and enhance current density. Voltage-gated sodium channels, in addition to voltage-gated K channels, regulate the excitability of sensory neurons. Clinical evidence has confirmed the contribution of sodium channels in visceral sensation. In a double-blind crossover clinical trial, the intra-rectal injection of lidocaine, a blocker of voltage gated Na channels, increased pain threshold and mitigated rectal hypersensitivity in patients with IBS.89 In an in vivo study on A-803467, a selective Nav1.8 sodium channel blocker, showed that this molecule can attenuate mechanical allodynia and thermal hyperalgesia in visceral tissues.90 Such therapeutic effects was also observed with administration of ambroxol, another Na+ channel blocker, in animal models of inflammatory pain in rats.91
Adrenergic Receptors
The receptors involved in the norepinephrine pathway belong to a subfamily of G protein-coupled receptors, which contain α and β subtypes. Chronic stress can cause overexpression of brain G proteins along with colonic adrenergic α2A receptors, which are able to induce visceral perception in IBS patients. Likewise, the norepinephrine reuptake transporter has a principal contributor in stress associated visceral perception.92 Winston et al93 reported that inhibition of adrenergic α1/α2 as well as β1/ β2 receptors significantly protects against heterotypic chronic stress-induced VH in rats. Within the distal colonic epithelium, β1 and β2 adrenergic receptors are implicated in the stimulation of electrogenic K+ currents with significant roles in colonic perception. β2 adrenergic receptors are expressed on primary afferent nociceptors and modulate pain perception in the animal gut. Systemic propranolol, an antagonist of β-adrenergic receptor, can significantly mitigate heterotypical, intermittent, and stress-induced VH in rats; however, an antagonist of the α-adrenergic receptor, phentolamine, did not affect visceromotor responses to colorectal distension. Administration of specific antagonists of β-adrenergic receptors showed that among β1, β2 and β3 receptors, only β2 antagonists obviously suppressed visceral sensitivity induced by heterotypical intermittent stress in animals. In fact, increased secretion of norepinephrine in serum can remarkably trigger β2 adrenergic receptors, which cause reduction of sensation threshold in colon-specific dorsal root ganglia.92,93
Glutamate Receptors
The main excitatory neurotransmitter within the CNS is glutamate. N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) and α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA) are the binding receptors of glutamate. In experimental models of VH, the function of the glutamate NMDA receptor is obviously enhanced within the anterior cingulate cortex.94 Likewise, persistent stimulation of the AMPA receptor, which has a key role in regulating rapid excitatory transmission as well as synaptic plasticity, is involved in hyperalgesia.95 AMPA receptor consists of four subunits, which include GluR1, GluR2, GluR3, and GluR4, which form tetramer structures. The GluR2 subunit participates in the development of VH which is induced via intracolonic administration of mustard oil.94 The non-selective antagonist of glutamate AMPA receptor, named 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione disodium salt, remarkably alleviated visceral perception induced by substance P.96
Sex Hormones
Sex hormones are significant contributor in the stimulation of the VH process in animal models. Estrogen participates in the development of the stress associated VH in female rats. One of the experimental methods for induction of stress-induced VH is neonatal maternal separation, which potentially results in the perception of pain in response to colorectal distension in rats.97 Likewise, it has been shown that estrogen is involved in colonic perception, which is stimulated by peripheral chemical sensitization. Estrogen contributes to the central sensitization of visceral pain through spinal activation of cAMP-response element binding protein pathways which modulate transcriptional signaling within the dorsal root ganglion as well as the CNS. In contrast, loss of gonadal hormones in ovariectomized rats significantly blocked the pathological process of VH, which is reversed by administration of exogenous estrogen.98,99
Cannabinoid Receptors
Accumulating evidence has suggested that the endocannabinoid pathway has a principal role in several neuronal processes. There are 2 major types of cannabinoid receptors, CB1 and CB2 receptors. CB1 receptors are associated with the adverse effect of cannabinoids, including catalepsy and hypothermia, and CB2 receptors, which are mainly located in the myenteric and submucosal plexus of the gastrointestinal tract, are associated with mitigating gut motility and pain perception.100 RQ-00202730, a selective agonist of the CB2 receptor, can remarkably alleviate visceral hyperalgesia stimulated by trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) in an animal model of IBS. The selective CB2 receptor agonist which has no adverse effect of cannabinoid pathway associated with CB1 receptor, can be considered as a safe and efficacious future drug for managing VH. Likewise, such a therapeutic effect has been reported by another selective CB2 receptor, PF-03550096, in animal models of VH induced by TNBS.100,101
Protease-activated Receptors
Proteases participate in nociception signaling through affecting several groups of ligands like protease-activated receptors (PAR). PAR is a member of the family of seven transmembrane domains, namely G-protein-coupled ligands, which is stimulated via proteolytic cleavage of their extracellular N-terminal domain and the ensuing binding of the newly released N-terminus. There are four main PAR receptors, which include PAR1, PAR2, PAR3, and PAR4. These receptors are directly or indirectly able to act on conducting and/or blocking pain sensation mediated by sensory neurons.102,103 In fact, PAR2 seems to be a pro-nociceptive receptor which participates in nociception and sensitization; though, PAR4 and PAR1 possess the potential to block nociceptive sensation.103,104 In addition, PAR4-deficient animals revealed more intensive visceral sensation induced by mustard oil (intracolonic administration) in comparison to wild-type mice.102,104 Administration of AYPGKF-NH(2), a PAR4 agonist peptide, noticeably alleviated the visceromotor response to colorectal distension in mice. Intracolonic administration of PAR4 agonists significantly mitigated hyperalgesia and allodynia in response to colorectal distension induced by PAR2 agonists. In fact, agonists of PAR4 modulate VH by suppression of free intracellular calcium mobilization which is stimulated by the pro-nociceptive PAR2 agonists.102,103
Subjects with post-infectious IBS showed an elevation in proteolytic activity in the colonic tissue. In patients with IBS, tryptase (which is released from mast cells), as well as serine proteases of bacteria (eg, gingipains-R) has a key contributor in the neuronal signaling of hypersensitivity via PAR2 stimulation. Some serine-proteases like thrombin are able to stimulate PAR1 but not PAR2, indicating their potential for mitigating nociceptive sensation.104,105 Antagonizing PAR2 receptors as well as activation of PAR1 and PAR4 receptors by selective agonists can be considered as novel therapeutic targets for managing VH in IBS patients.105
Gut Microflora
Initially after birth, the human baby becomes infected with a huge number of microorganisms which start to form the normal flora of the body.106,107 The main part of the body containing the microorganism is the intestine with a population of about one thousand CFU/mL of microbes which is hundreds of times higher than the human cells.108
The importance of gut microbiota is because of its activity to metabolize non-digestible large polysaccharide fibers, vitamin K synthesis, bowel cells growth, and immune system modulation as well as prevention of pathogen colonization.106 Once an alteration in the composition of gut microflora occurs, the result would be gastrointestinal complications, including changes in bowel habits, abdominal pain and bloating, which are common symptoms amongst IBS patients as well. In such situations, one of the safest therapeutic approaches (along with antibiotic or other therapies, if necessary) is to use probiotics.
Probiotics are special types of generally recognized as safe bacteria and yeasts with beneficial effects for human health and are famous for their positive role in the relief of signs and symptoms of several functional gut disorders including IBS.109 Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium species as well as Bacillus coagulans from bacteria and Saccharomyces boulardii as a yeast probiotic are the most well-known strains in the management of gastrointestinal disorders.110–112
In vitro and animal studies revealed that multispecies probiotic preparations exert beneficial effects via prevention of hyperpermeability, decrease in occludin (a protein with a crucial role in regulation of tight junctions) degradation by inflammatory phase enzymes, elevation of Zona occludens protein-1 (ZO-1) (which acts as cross-linkers in tight junctions) expression, and reduction in VH.113 Oral administration of Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus as well as their mixture remarkably reduced intestinal permeability as well as the contractile response of colonic smooth muscles in mice with IBS.41 The probiotics significantly alleviated VH symptoms of post-infectious IBS in animals which is mediated by suppression of intestinal inflammation and release of inflammatory cytokines. Early life administration of a mixture of 8 probiotic bacteria strains prevented the development of VH induced by neonatal maternal separation in rats via regulation of pain mediator transmission as well as inflammatory cytokines.114
A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial on moderate to severe IBS patients showed that a liquid non-dairy probiotic product containing Lactobacillus rhamnosus, Lactobacillus plantarum, Lactobacillus acidophilus, and Enterococcus faecium could enhance patient satisfaction due to decrease in abdominal pain.115 On the contrary, in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled setting, Roberts et al116 could not find a significant change in overall outcomes of constipation-predominant IBS and mixed stool form-IBS patients using a multispecies probiotic mixture. In a systematic review of Moayyedi et al,117 it is mentioned that in animal studies it was proposed a positive role for probiotics to reduce VH; though there are still controversial data on the potential of probiotics which requires high quality clinical trials to provide enough evidence.
Plant-derived Natural Compounds as Novel Drugs for Visceral Hypersensitivity
Curcumin
Curcumin is a second metabolite from turmeric, which has long been used as a spice because of its pleasant color and odor. Curcumin has a wide range of therapeutic properties including antioxidant,118 anti-inflammatory,119 antimicrobial,120 antidepressant,121 immunomodulatory122 and antinociceptive123 effects. Previously, a pilot study on turmeric extract suggested the beneficial effects of this medicinal plant in IBS patients.124 In an animal study, curcumin alleviated anxiety and depressive like behaviors in rats with IBS. Brain derived neurotrophic factor, 5-HT, and phosphorylation of cAMP-response element binding proteins were also modulated both in the peripheral nervous system and the CNS. The 5-HT1A receptor is suggested to be involved in the curcumin mechanism of action for the management of VH in rats with IBS.125 Another in vivo study showed a remarkable decrease by curcumin in visceromotor response to colorectal distension in rats.126 Ex vivo assessments on TNBS- treated jejunum confirmed the peripheral effect of curcumin on mesenteric afferent nerves. It was also demonstrated that curcumin, at least in part, interacts with TRPV1.126,127
Dicentrine
Dicentrine is a plant derived alkaloid with α adrenoceptor antagonist and anti-platelet activity.128,129 Oral administration of dicentrine in complete Freund’s adjuvant model of cutaneous inflammation demonstrated the antinociceptive effect in mechanical and cold hypersensitivity, as well as chronic inflammatory pain. Dicentrine reversed the pain caused by intraplantar injection of cinnamaldehyde, which is an activator of transient receptor potential cation channel 1 receptors which are involved in visceral pain caused by inflammatory conditions and stimuli.130 In addition, in the acetic acid-induced abdominal pain animal model, dicentrine could decrease visceral pain perception.131
Berberine
Berberine is an alkaloid found in several plants amongst which the most famous ones are Berberis spp. from the family Berberi-daceae.132,133 Anti-inflammatory,134 antioxidant,135 and anti-ulcer136 activity of berberine chloride have been demonstrated in several studies. Deng et al137 evaluated 12 berberine derivatives, which showed their remarkable activity for the treatment of IBS. In a post inflammation-IBS model induced by 4% acetic acid in rats, abdominal withdrawal reflex scores to colorectal distention were significantly lower in berberine treated animals compared with a placebo group, which represents the activity of berberine in reduction of VH. Berberine could also decrease defecation times and improved stool consistency. Inhibition of berberine effect by the concomitant administration of aminoguanidine (a nitric oxide synthetase inhibitor) suggests a role for nitric oxide in the visceral antinociceptive effect of berberine.138 Berberine could be proposed as an adjuvant treatment for IBS; however, recent studies showed an alteration in plasma level of berberine in animal models of IBS which suggests the necessity of dose adjustment for patient with IBS.139
Ginseng Saponins
Ginseng is an ancient medicinal herb native to China and eastern Asia with several health promoting effects.140 Ginsenosides, the active ingredients of ginseng belonging to the saponins class of phytochemicals, have an inhibitory activity of the 5-HT3A receptor. Total ginseng saponins were evaluated for their healing activity in a rat model of IBS which resulted in significant differences with negative control. In addition, 2 subtypes of ginseng saponins, protopanaxadiol ginsenosides and protopanaxatriol ginsenosides, showed that protopanaxatriols are more effective than protopanaxadiols.141 Total ginseng saponins showed antinociceptive activity in animal models of VH, which was performed by assessing the number of contractions in the external oblique muscles of rats during the colorectal distention period.142
Tetrahydropalmatine
Tetrahydropalmatine is an isoquinoline alkaloid mainly found in Stephania and Corydalis species.143 Pharmacological activities like beneficial effects in myocardial ischemia-reperfusion injury have been reported from this compound.144 JCM-16021 is a multi component herbal medicine composed of seven plants amongst which one is standardized based on tetrahydropalmatine amount. Antinociceptive effects of JCM-16021 were assessed in a neonatal-maternal separation model of visceral pain. Pain threshold in response to colorectal distention was significantly increased in the JCM-16021 treated group.145 Intragastric administration of tetrahydropalmatine noticeably suppressed primary hyperalgesia in response to both thermal and mechanical stimuli in rats. This molecule also significantly alleviated mirror-image thermal hyperalgesia induced by bee venom in comparison to the control group. Pre-administration of tetrahydropalmatine in the acetic acid-induced visceral pain group resulted in significant antinociceptive effect in comparison to the negative control group. Tetrahydropalmatine demonstrated modulatory effect on mechanical and thermal inflammatory pain hypersensitivity along with suppression of visceral nociception which is mediated by the supraspinal level of nociceptive signaling.143
Complementary and Alternative Therapies for the Management of Visceral Hypersensitivity in Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Due to the chronic undesirable complications of IBS which overshadows the quality of life, a growing number of patients are seeking complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) to manage their symptoms. It is reported that around half of IBS patients are using CAM along with their conventional medicaments.146,147 Traditional herbal formulas, acupuncture, meditation, hypnotherapy, as well as manipulative and body-based practices are amongst different types of CAM being used by IBS patients.148 Some of these methods like acupuncture-moxibustion and hypnotherapy showed beneficial effects on the relief of IBS symptoms and alleviation of visceroperception mediated by regulating brain-gut axis peptides, as well as mediators of the neuroendocrine system.149,150 Several clinical trials on different subgroups of patients with IBS confirmed the efficacy of acupuncture-moxibustion in managing gut complications, including improving low threshold of the rectal sensation, gut motility, and pain perception, indicating their therapeutic benefits on VH.149,151–153 Nevertheless, there is still a need for clinical trials to be set up for providing evidence on the dose, duration, and efficacy of different types of CAM.147
Discussion
IBS is considered as the most common disorder referred to gastroenterologists. Several conventional drugs have been used for IBS which are not satisfactory in managing symptoms and achieving remission and possess numerous side effects. IBS has a multi-factorial pathophysiology in which VH, disturbance in gut motility, inflammation and immune disturbance, as well as psychological factors are among the key contributors. A large body of evidence has suggested that IBS is considered as a heterogeneous disorder with VH as a pivotal biological hallmark.10,23,33
VH means decreased thresholds of stimuli perception generated from the gastrointestinal tract, which plays as a key pathophysiological mechanism in nociceptive sensation in large subgroups of patients with functional gastrointestinal disorders, particularly IBS.33,39 The exact etiology of VH has not been recognized; however, it is hypothesized that both peripheral and central neural mechanisms are involved in the pain sensitization.154 Given the fact that VH is considered as a paramount clinical manifestation observed in patients with IBS, assessment practices of pain sensation such as modern imaging methods, as well as the barostat method, possess an increased interest to understand mechanisms of visceroperception in IBS.13
Dysregulation in the afferent part of the brain–gut axis possesses the potential to induce VH. It has been reported that several novel compounds which possess multiple gastrointestinal pharmacological effects can be considered as future drugs for managing VH in IBS patients. However, evidence indicating the efficacy, safety and tolerability of the pharmacological agents for managing VH in patients with IBS are restricted. Gut tissue possesses a wide exposure to external agents such as microbes and nutritional compounds. Several biological cascades are implicated in the physiologic function of the gut including neural, immunological, and mucosal epithelial cell performance. The complex interaction among the neuroimmune pathway, gut-brain axis, as well as intestinal epithelial cells stimulates inflammatory and motility response, resulting in visceroperception and a low threshold of nociception.155 The pharmacological research on selective drugs based on targeting specific ligands can result in providing novel effective therapies for modulating persistent visceral hyperalgesia. The current paper has reviewed the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying therapeutic targeting for providing future drugs in order to protect or treat visceroperception and pain sensitization in IBS patients. Figure illustrates the pharmacological aspects of novel therapeutic targeting for the management of VH in IBS.
Numerous molecular mediators and receptors participating in pain perception and visceroperception including histamine-1 receptors, 5-HT receptors, transient receptor potential vanilloid type I, tachykinins ligands, opioid receptors, voltage-gated channels, Trk receptors, protease-activated receptors, adrenergic system ligands, cannabinoid receptors, sex hormones, and glutamate receptors, are considered as specific molecular targets for future treatment of VH. Gut microbiota have also attracted a lot of attention from physicians around the world as a part of treatment in IBS patients. Multispecies probiotic products have shown effectiveness in controlling some abdominal symptoms and improving the quality of life in a number of human studies. In addition, preclinical evaluation exhibited the therapeutic effect of probiotics on gut motility and visceroperception in animal models of IBS. The Table shows a summary of novel drugs and their underlying mechanisms for the management of VH.
Along with the mentioned pharmacological targets with the potential to manage VH, natural compounds could be considered as novel future treatments for VH in IBS patients. Among the wide range of evaluated molecules, in vitro and animal studies suggest a positive role for curcumin, dicentrine, ginseng saponins, berberine and tetrahydropalmatine in the improvement of visceral pain perception; however, more mechanistic studies as well as clinical trials are necessary to confirm the effectiveness of these novel components. In addition, various CAM approaches, including physiotherapy, traditional medicines, acupuncture, mind-body directed interventions, as well as psychosocial-directed therapies with modest but proven efficacy, are currently employed and are able to help IBS patients in managing VH and persistent visceral pain.
A wide range of novel pharmacological compounds as well as natural molecules is capable of improving visceral complications of IBS; however, the most important limitation on practical use of these products is the lack of enough clinical evidence which requires more studies for better understanding of the mechanisms of action, safety, and efficacy of the above mentioned agents.
In conclusion, it has been confirmed that VH has an important role in IBS pathology and in the severity of patient complications indicating that managing VH can remarkably modulate the symptoms of IBS. Preclinical and clinical evaluations of pharmacological targets with the potential to prevent or cure VH in IBS conditions are discussed in the current review in order to provide more efficacious and targeted medicaments rather than conventional treatments for hypersensitive IBS patients. Further well-designed controlled clinical trials are mandatory in order to confirm the therapeutic efficacy and safety of novel pharmacological compounds on VH in IBS patients.
Acknowledgements
Authors wish to thank the Iran National Science Foundation and The National Elite Foundation for the support of the first author postdoctoral program.
| Source | Agents as future drugs | Cell/ receptor targets | Therapeutic effects in managing VH | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chemical | 5-aminosalicylic acid | Intestinal immune cells | ↓Inflammation and pain perception | 19, 49, 50 |
| A-803467 | Selective Nav1.8 sodium channel blocker | ↓Mechanical allodynia and thermal hyperalgesia | 90 | |
| Alosetron | 5-HT3 receptor antagonist | ↑Volume thresholds, ↓Colonic compliance, ↓Emotional motor system of brain activity and modulation of the gut sensitivity | 60, 61 | |
| Ambroxol | Na+channel blocker | ↓Inflammatory pain | 91 | |
| Asimadoline | κ-opioid receptor agonist | ↓Pain sensation, ↓Hyperalgesia in functional dyspepsia | 78–80 | |
| AYPGKF-NH2 | PAR4 agonist peptide | ↓Visceromotor response to colorectal distension | 102, 103 | |
| Capsazepine | TRPV1 receptor antagonist | ↓Inflammation and visceral pain | 67, 72 | |
| CNQX | Non-selective glutamate AMPA receptor antagonist | ↓Visceral perception induced by substance P | 96 | |
| Ebastine and fexofenadine | Histamine-1-receptor antagonists | ↓Stress associated VH | 54 | |
| Eluxadoline | μ-opioid receptor agonist and δ-opioid receptor antagonist | ↑Pain threshold | 80, 81 | |
| Fedotozine | κ-opioid receptor agonist | ↓Pain sensation, ↓Volume or pressure stimuli perception | 78–80 | |
| K252A | TrkA antagonist | ↓VH in colorectal distension | 84 | |
| Ketotifen | Histamine-1-receptor antagonist and mast cell stabilizer | ↓Hyperalgesia, discomfort and abdominal pain | 56 | |
| Lidocaine | Voltage gated Na+ channels blocker | ↑Pain threshold, ↓Rectal hypersensitivity | 89 | |
| Mibefradil, ethosuximide, and NP078585 | Calcium channel antagonists | ↓Butyrate-induced VH | 88 | |
| Nepadutant and saredutant | NK2 receptor antagonists | Modulation the colorectal hypersensitivity to distension | 74–77 | |
| PF-03550096 | Selective CB2 receptor agonist | ↓Visceral hyperalgesia | 101 | |
| Propranolol | β-adrenergic receptor antagonist | ↓Heterotypical intermittent stress-induced VH | 92, 93 | |
| RQ-00202730 | Selective CB2 receptor agonist | ↓Visceral hyperalgesia | 100 | |
| SB366791 | TRPV1 receptor antagonist | ↓Thermal hyperalgesia | 71 | |
| SR-140333 and MEN-10930 | Selective NK1 receptor antagonists | ↓Inflammatory associated hyperalgesia | 73–75 | |
| SR-142801 | Selective NK3 receptor antagonist | ↓Inflammatory associated VH | 75–77 | |
| TAK-242 | Specific TLR4 receptor antagonist | ↓Chronic stress-induced VH | 53 | |
| Tegaserod | Partial 5-HT4 receptor agonist | ↓Sensitivity to rectal distension, Improved visceral sensation | 62–64 | |
| Natural | Berberine | Involvement of nitric oxide synthetase | ↓Abdominal withdrawal reflex score to colorectal distention, ↓Defecation times, Improvement of stool consistency | 138 |
| Curcumin | Involvement of TRPV1 and 5-HT1a receptors, Modulation of BDNF, 5-HT and pCREB | ↓Visceromotor response to colorectal distension, Modulation of depressive behavior in IBS | 125, 126 | |
| Dicentrine | α-adrenoceptor antagonist, Involvement of TRPA1 receptors | ↓Visceral pain perception | 130, 131 | |
| Ginseng saponins | 5-HT3a receptor blocker | Antinociceptive effect in VH | 141 | |
| Probiotics | Gut microflora | ↓Intestinal permeability and contractile response of colonic smooth muscle, ↓VH symptoms of post-infectious IBS, Regulation of pain transmission mediators and inflammatory cytokines | 41, 113–115 | |
| Tetrahydropalmatine | Not identified | ↑Pain threshold, ↓Primary hyperalgesia due to thermal and mechanical stimuli, Antinociceptive effect | 143, 145 |